AI Struggles to Capture the 'Dramatic' Aesthetic with Scenario

The ‘dramatic’ aesthetic, characterized by strong contrasts, heightened emotions, and a sense of grandeur, is a staple in visual storytelling. It’s often used to evoke feelings of awe, suspense, or even tragedy. But can AI truly capture this aesthetic? This blog post delves into the challenges AI faces in understanding and replicating the ‘dramatic’ style, using a recent experiment as a case study. We’ll explore the model’s strengths and weaknesses, and discuss the implications for the future of AI art.

Created with: scenario

A Solitary Figure Against the Industrial Sunset

A woman stands alone on a rooftop, silhouetted against a fiery sunset over a sprawling industrial city. The scene evokes a sense of melancholy and contemplation, with the vastness of the cityscape highlighting her isolation. Yet, a glimmer of hope shines through in the dramatic beauty of the sky.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Melancholy, yet hopeful ; A lone figure, silhouetted against the setting sun, standing atop a crumbling building; long shot; Heroism; A cityscape with smoke rising from factories in the distance; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A woman standing on a rooftop overlooking a cityscape at sunset. The city is industrial, with smokestacks and factories in the background. The sun is setting behind the buildings, casting a warm glow over the scene.

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : melancholy, hopeful, contemplative

Quality

Entropy : 6.70

Noise : 100

Prompt Clip Score : 0.35

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.80

Image errors : The image is slightly blurry, particularly in the background. The woman’s face is also somewhat obscured.

Unveiling the Secrets of the Past: A Mysterious Map Room

Affiliate Links

Stable Diffusion with Python

Master Stable Diffusion for AI image generation using Python. Control and customize your creations.

Stable Diffusion Web UI on AWS

Deploy Stable Diffusion Web UI on AWS with this comprehensive guide.

Mastering Midjourney: AI Art Guide

Unlock Midjourney V6 features and create exceptional AI art.

Step into a dimly lit room where history whispers from the walls. A weathered world map sprawls across a wooden table, illuminated by flickering candlelight. Surrounded by navigational tools and a compass, the scene evokes a sense of mystery and intrigue, inviting you to imagine the stories and adventures that have unfolded on the maps.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Intriguing, mysterious ; A weathered map, spread out on a rickety wooden table, with a worn compass resting on it; close-up; Adventure; A dimly lit room with flickering candlelight; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A wooden table in a dimly lit room with candles and a map, the focus is on the map

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : mysterious, antique, adventurous

Quality

Entropy : 6.77

Noise : 102

Prompt Clip Score : 0.32

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.30

Image errors : The image is slightly blurry in the center of the map.

Surreal Feast: A Young Woman’s Unsettling Pizza Paradise

A young woman, headphones on, sits amidst a mountain of pizza boxes and soda cans, creating a jarring contrast between the mundane and the surreal. The scene evokes a sense of unsettling irony, leaving viewers questioning the nature of this bizarre feast.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Intense, focused ; A pair of hands, gripping a joystick, sweat dripping onto the buttons; close-up; Gaming; A dimly lit room with flickering monitor light, surrounded by empty pizza boxes and soda cans; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A young woman wearing headphones is sitting at a table covered in pizza boxes. There are also soda cans and other items on the table.

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : melancholy, introspective, surreal

Quality

Entropy : 6.71

Noise : 104

Prompt Clip Score : 0.33

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.20

Image errors : No visible errors or artifacts

Vibrant European Marketplace with a Leaning Tower

Capture the lively atmosphere of a bustling European marketplace, with a historic leaning tower adding a dramatic touch of perspective and scale to the scene.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Awe-inspiring, curious ; A group of tourists, huddled together, looking up at a towering ancient monument; medium shot; Tourism; A bustling marketplace with vendors selling souvenirs and local crafts; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A bustling market square in a European city with a tall leaning tower in the background. People are walking and shopping at the stalls.

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : vibrant, bustling, historic

Quality

Entropy : 6.68

Noise : 103

Prompt Clip Score : 0.31

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.80

Image errors : The image has a slightly artificial look, and the texture of the buildings is somewhat flat.

A Moment of Departure: Longing and Anticipation on the Platform

A woman in a blue coat and hat stands poised on a train platform, suitcase in hand, her gaze cast downwards. The train, a blur of motion in the background, hints at a journey about to begin. The scene evokes a sense of nostalgia, romance, and adventure, with the woman’s posture suggesting a mix of longing and anticipation for what lies ahead.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Nostalgic, bittersweet ; A worn suitcase, sitting on a train platform, with a single ticket protruding from it; medium shot; Travel; A bustling train station with people rushing to and fro; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A woman in a stylish hat and blue coat stands on a train platform waiting to board a train. She has a suitcase in her hand. In the background, a man sits in the doorway of a train car.

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : stylish, elegant, anticipation

Quality

Entropy : 6.68

Noise : 95

Prompt Clip Score : 0.31

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.20

Image errors : No noticeable artifacts or errors in the image.

A Family Gathering, Bathed in Warm Nostalgia

A simple yet heartwarming scene of a family sharing a meal together. The rustic setting and the woman’s gaze towards the viewer evoke a sense of intimacy and nostalgia, transporting us to a time of simpler pleasures.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Warm, intimate ; A family gathered around a worn dining table, sharing a simple meal; medium shot; Family; A dimly lit kitchen with faded wallpaper and chipped paint; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A family sits at a kitchen table, having a meal. The table is set with plates and bowls, and there are food items on the table. The room is decorated with wallpaper, and there is a window in the background.

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : warm, cozy, intimate

Quality

Entropy : 6.75

Noise : 101

Prompt Clip Score : 0.31

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.20

Image errors : The image is somewhat blurry, especially in the background.

A Boy’s Journey Through Time

A young boy gazes out the window of a train, his expression filled with nostalgia and wonder as the lush green valley whizzes by. A distant train adds to the sense of journey and the passage of time, creating a poignant and contemplative scene.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Wonder, anticipation ; A young boy, gazing out of a train window, watching the world go by; close-up; Adventure; A train speeding through a rural landscape with fields and forests; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A young boy is looking out the window of a train, watching a train pass by in the distance, a beautiful rural landscape is visible outside the window

Aesthetic Score : 0.75

Mode : nostalgic, whimsical, contemplative

Quality

Entropy : 6.66

Noise : 104

Prompt Clip Score : 0.37

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.10

Image errors : The image is a painting and some of the details are exaggerated or unrealistic, it is slightly blurry.

Radiant Beauty: A Moment of Intimacy and Warmth

A young woman with dark hair, dressed in a light brown dress, holds a vintage-style light bulb that illuminates her face, creating a soft, romantic, and warm atmosphere. The light from the bulb forms a halo effect around her face, emphasizing her beauty and adding a touch of mystery to the scene.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Nostalgic, sentimental ; A weathered hand, holding a worn photograph, with a faded smile on the face in the picture; close-up; Family; A dimly lit room with a single lamp casting a warm glow; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A young woman with dark hair, wearing a light brown patterned blouse, is holding a vintage-style lamp with a glowing filament bulb. The background is a soft brown wall, creating a warm and cozy atmosphere.

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : romantic, vintage, intimate

Quality

Entropy : 6.80

Noise : 90

Prompt Clip Score : 0.27

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.20

Image errors : The lighting seems slightly artificial, and the image has a subtle filter applied, giving it a slightly vintage look. The background wall has a faint texture that could be more subtle.

Campfire Tales Under a Starry Sky

Four friends gather around a crackling campfire, sharing stories and laughter under a breathtaking starry sky. The tranquil lake and majestic mountains create a serene backdrop for their cozy evening, capturing the essence of friendship and wonder.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Joyful, camaraderie ; A group of friends, huddled together around a campfire, sharing stories and laughter; medium shot; Adventure; A campsite under a starry night sky with a crackling fire; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : Four young adults sit around a campfire in the woods, with a lake and a starry sky in the background.

Aesthetic Score : 0.7

Mode : cozy, nostalgic, adventurous

Quality

Entropy : 6.49

Noise : 108

Prompt Clip Score : 0.33

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.80

Image errors : No significant errors. The image is well-composed and the lighting is even.

Lost in the Fog: A Moment of Solitude

A woman, shrouded in mystery, walks down a cobblestone street bathed in the soft glow of lampposts. The fog hangs heavy, adding to the melancholic atmosphere and leaving her path uncertain. This evocative scene captures a moment of quiet contemplation, inviting viewers to ponder the woman’s journey and the secrets she carries.

Prompt

Neo-realist: Lonely, introspective ; A lone figure, walking down a deserted street, with a suitcase in hand; long shot; Travel; A city street at night with flickering streetlights and empty sidewalks; cinematic

Characteristic

Shot : A woman in a long coat walks away from the viewer down a cobblestone street at night, with a suitcase in her hand.

Aesthetic Score : 0.8

Mode : mysterious, lonely, nostalgic

Quality

Entropy : 6.72

Noise : 117

Prompt Clip Score : 0.30

AI Evaluation

Likelihood of AI : 0.80

Image errors : The image has some slight imperfections, such as the repeating patterns in the cobblestone and the slightly blurry edges of the buildings. There are also some slight inconsistencies in the lighting.

Conclusion

The results show that the generative AI model performed well in terms of camera position and shot analysis, but struggled with aesthetic analysis.

Here’s a breakdown:

• Camera Position: The model scored 0.45, which is considered below average. This suggests that the model didn’t accurately capture the intended camera positions described in the prompt.
• Shot Analysis: The model scored 0.61, which is considered good. This indicates that the model was able to understand the scene described in the prompt and create a shot that aligns with it.
• Aesthetic Analysis: The model scored 0.04, which is considered very poor. This means that the generated image’s aesthetic significantly deviated from the expected aesthetic described in the prompt.

Overall, the model demonstrates a good understanding of scene composition and shot types, but struggles to accurately translate the desired aesthetic into the final image.